Giants sign Wilson

[MightyGiants]

https://x.com/rydunleavy/status/1904676588987306463

[Gmo11]

I think Giants should start feeling out who wants the third pick

I love Carter and Hunter .... But I don't think Graham is too far behind talent wise and would also fill a major need

If we can get Graham and pickup another 2nd or 3rd round pick I think you do it .... My hope would still be able to trade back into the first if Dart is still available .... Give up the second , 3rd comp pick , and maybe next years second or third round pick

We get Graham and Dart


This is also depending if Dart gets to post pick 15 in the first round

If not keep the picks and just draft Milroe .... And have him learn

Why do anything at all to get Dart now? Or any QB? They've made it clear they are going all in to win now as per the mandate of their bunbling idiot of an owner. So what gives them the best chance to win? Dart as a 3rd stringer or a new RG? Here's a hint: it ain't Dart. I'd be completely shocked if they traded up for any QB at all and surprised if they even drafted one before the 4th or 5th round. 

They clearly think they can find 4 new starters in the draft again that actually perform well and that they can make the playoffs with Russ. Personally I think this is dumb because Russ is pretty much cooked and not much of an upgrade to Jameis if at all. But they have no incentive to think about next year or the year after so I understand it.

[nb587]

Maybe this is thinking too much but I would not rule out Sanders with the 3rd pick.  Signing Wilson could mean we're drafting Hunter or Carter and it might nudge the Browns into taking Carter with their pick.  If they think he's generational, why let the Giants have him.  As it is, the Browns have the 1st pick in the 2nd round so they could pick whatever QB is available

[MightyGiants]

https://x.com/AndrewBrandt/status/1904668041444458624

[Rosehill Jimmy]

Well for all of those who were dead set against AR coming here, sleep well tonight

[Philosophers]

More chances to have success with one QB if multiple available.  Part of me thinks they may want this for a couple of seasons in lieu of drafting anyone.  If no QB, they have all picks to improve other positions. 

I still like them drafting say a Milroe in round 2 or 3 and letting him learn from these guys.

Now I think Sanders is definitely out at 3.

[MightyGiants]

Wait. What?  What's that saying that if you have two would-be starters, you don't have any?

What's the upside?  They DON'T take a QB, you win enough games with a couple of decent journeymen (which is what Wilson is now) to ensure that you're not in a position to take a top QB next year.

Do they draft a QB and just have them sit?

I'm sorry, this makes no sense to me.

One way to ensure you draft a QB in the next draft is to make trades in this draft that get you extra picks in next year's draft

[spiderblue43]

I'm only happy if this means BPA available at 3..or a trade down..adding picks..a rookie QB seems a stretch now..ol dt..wr..rb..depth..wait until next year perhaps..if the roster really gets improved on defense..then I'm good..long way to go still..but I didn't want the cost of Ward or Sanders

[MightyGiants]

https://x.com/HaydenWinks/status/1904680204716642403

[Ed Vette]

In the process, just lowered Rodgers market value.

[GloryDays]

Looks to me that due to the inability to assess talent and potential, they hedge their bets by numbers. They had two mediocre QBs on the roster, they go and sign two others that their own teams did not want, hoping that may be one of the four would be ok!
They have done the same thing with the O line and the TE and pass-rushers, to a degree!!

[killarich]

Why do anything at all to get Dart now? Or any QB? They've made it clear they are going all in to win now as per the mandate of their bunbling idiot of an owner. So what gives them the best chance to win? Dart as a 3rd stringer or a new RG? Here's a hint: it ain't Dart. I'd be completely shocked if they traded up for any QB at all and surprised if they even drafted one before the 4th or 5th round. 

They clearly think they can find 4 new starters in the draft again that actually perform well and that they can make the playoffs with Russ. Personally I think this is dumb because Russ is pretty much cooked and not much of an upgrade to Jameis if at all. But they have no incentive to think about next year or the year after so I understand it.

I get you don't like that we signed multiple vets .... But if Joe has another draft like he had last year .... Giants can be a 7-9 win team .... Which will put us in QB hell

So that is why you trade back into the first for Dart if it's possible .... Because we may not get that qb next year

[killarich]

In the process, just lowered Rodgers market value.

He did it to himself

I wanted him at first

But considering the resigning of Slayton .... And Hyatt on life support .... Wilson and his still above average deep ball makes better sense for this team

[MightyGiants]

I think Giants should start feeling out who wants the third pick

I love Carter and Hunter .... But I don't think Graham is too far behind talent wise and would also fill a major need

If we can get Graham and pickup another 2nd or 3rd round pick I think you do it .... My hope would still be able to trade back into the first if Dart is still available .... Give up the second , 3rd comp pick , and maybe next years second or third round pick

We get Graham and Dart


This is also depending if Dart gets to post pick 15 in the first round

If not keep the picks and just draft Milroe .... And have him learn

If the Giants trade down, it should be for picks in next year's draft class, so they are in a position to grab a QB then

[MightyGiants]

Why do anything at all to get Dart now? Or any QB? They've made it clear they are going all in to win now as per the mandate of their bunbling idiot of an owner. So what gives them the best chance to win? Dart as a 3rd stringer or a new RG? Here's a hint: it ain't Dart. I'd be completely shocked if they traded up for any QB at all and surprised if they even drafted one before the 4th or 5th round. 

They clearly think they can find 4 new starters in the draft again that actually perform well and that they can make the playoffs with Russ. Personally I think this is dumb because Russ is pretty much cooked and not much of an upgrade to Jameis if at all. But they have no incentive to think about next year or the year after so I understand it.

If they like a QB, they can still draft him and let him sit.   I could see an uber-talented but raw QB prospect like Milroe being an interest choice